Gigino’s Pizzeria, Solvay

No, the Pizza Geek didn’t give up eating and reviewing pizza for lent! I will admit that most of my at-home computer time lately has been taken up with tax preparation. I’ve still been eating pizza, so it is time to start clearing the hopper and get the reviews written.

Gigino's Pizzeria, SolvayIt wasn’t very long ago that I made a swing through Solvay to check out the area’s pizza shops. Since then, another has appeared: Gigino’s Pizzeria at 2409 Milton Ave., across the street from the Solvay Diner. This didn’t LOOK like a totally new pizzeria, so I’m going to guess that some sort of food operation has been here before. There is no seating; delivery is available for a fairly wide area on the west side. The menu lists a generally typical selection of pizzeria food.

I decided to “swing both ways” and sample both a traditional slice from a round pizza, and a thicker piece of sheet pizza, cut into a rectangle. The first slice was 1/6th of a 16″ pie, and the second was likely cut from a half sheet. Gigino's Pizzeria, SolvayI’ve gotten in to the habit of first noticing the crust and how it was baked, probably because I always flip it over first to take a picture. As you can see, the round slice was very brown, with the unmistakable sheen and crispiness of being baked on a lightly oiled pan. The splotchy white areas are usually caused by pockets of CO2 that form when the flattened dough is allowed to rise for a while on the pan. Contrast that with the other slice, which had very little bottom browning for some reason.

Gigino's Pizzeria, SolvayThickness of the round slice ranged from 1/4″ to 1/2″, and the rectangle was 1/2″ to 1″. In both cases, the edge was well-browned and crispy, with a soft, well-structured interior. As pizza crusts go, it was pretty good. Sauce on the round slice was mostly absorbed into the crust and cheese, and although there was a tad more sauce on the thick slice, it was difficult to assess much about the flavor. All I can really say is that it was middle of the road, neither obviously bad or obviously good. Cheese was Grande, applied in good proportion to everything else, but congealed into a sheet. The pepperoni cupped and charred a little, and added a good zing. Some additional spice was apparently sprinkled on the top after the pizza was prepared. You can’t really see it, but some parmesan cheese was also added.

Overall, this pizza falls squarely in the middle of the scale. You probably wouldn’t go out of your way to get it, but it’s OK if that’s where you happen to end up. (By the way, it occurs to me that the absorbed sauce can possibly be explained by advance preparation. A family member who used to work in a pizzeria recently told me how they prepared for rush times by placing dough on pans, adding sauce and cheese, and letting them sit in a rack until it was time to add toppings and bake – sometimes hours later. That extra rise time can be good for the crust, but I think it would promote absorption of moisture from the sauce and create the vanishing sauce effect seen here. Disclaimer: I don’t know if this type of advance preparation is used at Gigino’s, I’m just having a rambling geek moment.)  For a rating, let’s call this 3.0 out of 5 slices on the Pizza Geek scale.

Summary – Pros: good bready crust. Cons: sauce absorbed and unremarkable.

What do YOU think? Have you tried pizza from Gigino’s? Click the comment link below and tell us about it!

Crust: ****
Sauce: ***
Cheese: ***
Toppings: ****
Bang/Buck: ****

Gigino's Pizzeria on Urbanspoon

About these ads

About pizzageek

Perhaps being an engineer makes me too picky, but I'm in search of really GREAT pizza in Syracuse.
This entry was posted in 13209 - Solvay/Lakeland, by the slice, delivery, medium crust, slices rating: 3.0. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Gigino’s Pizzeria, Solvay

  1. Meghan says:

    It was a florist before it was Gigino’s, just thought I’d let you know! :)

  2. KMR says:

    I had a Gigino’s pie about two weeks ago, it was 100% unremarkable. Not bad pizza, just nothing that stands out that can be complimented. While the crust on my pizza was “bread like” in interior texture and exterior crisp of the crust, it was lacking taste – almost like the sole reason the dough exists was as a platform to carry the sauce, cheese and toppings.

    I too found little sauce on my pizza, there were a few areas of thicker sauce accumulation, but the vast majority of the pizza had little of it. The cheese was OK. The toppings we had, mushrooms, were canned.

    I must say though that when we entered Gigino’s store to pickup our pizza, I was impressed by the presentation and overall appearance of the pizzas they had on display. Even our own pizza had decent aesthetic qualities, although unfortunately my taste buds weren’t as excited once we were eating.

    The other issue I have with Gigino’s is the pizza sizing. A large pizza from Gigino’s is on the “medium” side of sizing. My “large” pizza measured 13.5″. As I’ve said before, a large really should be 15-17″, it seems most independent shops conform to a 16″ measurement as a large. So 13-14″ is definitely on the smaller side.

    • pizzageek says:

      Thanks KMR,

      As always, I appreciate feedback, especially when it includes details. That’s what I envisioned when I started pizza blogging, that fellow pizza lovers would engage in ongoing dialogue.


  3. Justin B says:


    Check out the Romans Pizza at the Paradise Market. They have received better rating than most full time pizza shops. Thats pretty sad for the full time shops. Kudos to the Romans Pizza at Paradise Market for a weekend gig of a pizza stand!

  4. Mia says:

    I called to order some pizza with a coupon that would expire a month later, but they would not honor the coupon. upset im bringing my bussiness else where

  5. solvaypizzabuyer says:

    Bought their pizzas and, while they’re nothing special, they were ok. Wings were always burnt to a crisp, though. They were asked to donate a door prize for a good cause and they refused. They won’t get my business any more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s